Among the items stolen were a custom-built, purple sparkle baritone Telecaster guitar with a hand-painted headstock made for Nancy Wilson, and a vintage 1966 Gibson EM-50 mandolin that Paul Moak has played for over 25 years. They band initially offered a reward for the return of their instruments.

Atlantic City police say Garfield Bennett took a guitar and mandolin from the band Heart the night of their show at the venue's Etess Arena.